Manchester City seized a commanding lead in the Carabao Cup semi-final first leg with a 2-0 victory over Newcastle United, thanks to goals from new signing Antoine Semenyo and substitute Rayan Cherki. But here's where it gets controversial... Semenyo, who completed a £65m move from Bournemouth just last week, has already proven his worth, yet his eligibility to play on Tuesday night sparked debate following a recent rule change. Newcastle’s frustration was palpable, especially after hitting the woodwork twice when the score was still goalless. Manchester City’s goalkeeper, James Trafford, made a crucial save to deny Yoane Wissa, while Bruno Guimaraes also struck the bar moments later. Wissa’s missed opportunity from close range further highlighted Newcastle’s misfortune.
Semenyo’s opener came after a well-worked move involving Jeremy Doku and Bernardo Silva, though he later had a goal disallowed, much to the delight of the St James’ Park crowd. Newcastle’s evening turned from bad to worse when Cherki doubled City’s lead deep into stoppage time, leaving the home fans deflated. And this is the part most people miss... Despite the defeat, Newcastle’s supporters had dared to dream, recalling last week’s dramatic late comeback against Leeds United. However, there was no such heroics this time, as Cherki’s late strike felt like a knockout blow.
The atmosphere at St James’ Park was electric, with a massive flag display and raucous chants, but it wasn’t enough to inspire a turnaround. Trafford, who rejected a move to Newcastle last summer, faced relentless boos throughout the match. Eddie Howe’s side now faces an uphill battle, having only won once at the Etihad and failing to score there since 2021. Boldly put, can Newcastle break the curse and stage a miraculous comeback?
Howe remains optimistic, stating, ‘We’re still alive... football can conjure up magical moments.’ Yet, history favors City, who have progressed from their last six Carabao Cup semi-finals, lifting the trophy each time. With the second leg at the Etihad on February 4, Pep Guardiola’s side looks poised to return to Wembley for the first time since 2021.
What do you think? Can Newcastle overturn the deficit, or is City’s path to the final all but secured? Let us know in the comments!
